WoW TWW 11.1 Undermine(d) Mythic+ Tank Tier List

As TWW Patch 11.1 approaches, the Mythic+ tanking landscape undergoes significant transformation. Understanding these fundamental changes is crucial for adapting your playstyle and maximizing performance in the new season. This analysis draws from extensive PTR testing, community feedback, and Blizzard’s latest balance adjustments, providing you with actionable insights for Season 2 preparation.

Reduced One-Shot Mechanics

Blizzard has dramatically decreased the frequency of lethal tankbuster abilities that plagued Season 1. While tanks won’t achieve the near-invincibility seen in Dragonflight Seasons 3-4, the reduction in instant-death scenarios creates a more manageable tanking environment. You’ll still need to maintain active mitigation, but the constant fear of sudden elimination has been substantially mitigated.

Shifted Difficulty to Healers

The responsibility balance has fundamentally shifted—where tanks bore the heaviest burden in Season 1, healers now face increased pressure. Many high-damage abilities now randomly target party members instead of focusing exclusively on tanks. This paradigm shift means your pull decisions must now consider your healer’s capabilities and your group’s overall survivability, not just your personal durability.

New Damage Profile Dynamics

Season 2 introduces a completely different damage composition dominated by bleed effects and unblockable damage-over-time mechanics. The Dwarf racial ability Stoneform becomes exceptionally valuable for its bleed removal capability, making race selection more impactful than previous seasons.

Threat Generation Improvements

Following community feedback about underwhelming tank damage, Blizzard implemented a universal 15-20% auto-attack damage increase across all tank specializations. Combined with enhanced threat generation, maintaining aggro becomes significantly less stressful. However, these improvements won’t completely prevent aggressive DPS players from pulling threat during cooldown bursts at pull initiation.

The power disparity between top and bottom tank specs has narrowed considerably compared to Season 1. While performance differences remain noticeable, the gap is substantially smaller. Community meta preferences will inevitably influence group composition decisions, but understanding each specialization’s strengths and limitations will help you make informed choices regardless of prevailing trends.

E Tier: Brewmaster Monk

Brewmaster maintains its position as the most technically demanding tank specialization with an exceptionally high skill ceiling. The performance differential between competent and masterful Brewmasters remains enormous—proper Purified Chi management, precise Celestial Brew timing, and exploiting 100% dodge windows for critical tankbusters separates average from exceptional players.

Critical weaknesses plague the specialization:

• Demands continuous healer support, creating complications during a season where healers face increased demands
• Tier set bonuses enhance defensive uptime without addressing fundamental survivability concerns
• Celestial Brew continues underperforming despite recent enhancements
• Struggles significantly against prevalent bleed and magical damage sources
• Recent adjustments provide minimal improvement to longstanding mechanical issues

Additionally, Brewmaster provides minimal group utility compared to alternative tank options. These cumulative deficiencies position Brewmaster at the bottom of our tier rankings.

D Tier: Protection Warrior

Protection Warriors occupy the D tier while undergoing transitional changes leading to Patch 11.1’s planned rework. Interestingly, Blizzard cites high Actions Per Minute (APM) as justification, though Protection Paladins demonstrate even higher APM requirements.

The ongoing rework introduces substantial sustainability challenges:

• Increased Ignore Pain downtime due to reduced rage generation
• Vulnerability against bleed effects, magical damage, and healing absorption mechanics
• Season 2’s emphasis on unblockable damage disadvantages block-reliant specializations

Protection Warriors retain notable advantages:

• Spell Reflect provides exceptional value in specific encounter scenarios
• Consistent area-of-effect and single-target damage output
• Comprehensive crowd control arsenal including area silence, Shockwave, multi-target fears, and Storm Bolt

Unfortunately, these benefits don’t sufficiently counterbalance their Season 2 weaknesses. The current damage profile simply doesn’t favor their defensive approach, though future tuning adjustments may improve their positioning.

C Tier: Guardian Druid

Patch 11.1’s Druid talent tree overhaul provides meaningful benefits to Bear tanks. Ursol’s Warding represents a significant addition that enhances their capability against magical damage—historically their primary vulnerability. While this magical damage reduction talent marks improvement, its talent point cost feels excessive for the modest survivability enhancement it delivers against magic-based tankbusters. Additionally, Bears continue experiencing difficulties with bleed damage mitigation.

Guardian Druids demonstrate improved performance against standard physical attacks. They maintain solid mob control capabilities and can manage larger pull sizes than some alternatives, particularly during Incarnation activation.

Their damage potential remains somewhat constrained within Season 2’s Mythic+ meta, where pull size limitations derive more from group and healer capacity than tank survivability.

Guardian Druids possess the weakest damage profile among tank specializations, especially during single-target engagements. This limitation is partially offset by their class-specific Mark of the Wild buff, which maintains S-tier status in Mythic+ content.

Overall, Guardian Druids enter Season 2 in reasonable condition—definitely stronger than Season 1—though they may require additional buffs to achieve meta relevance.

B Tier: Blood Death Knight

Blood Death Knights secure third position with a B-tier ranking. Their core identity remains consistent in Season 2, preserving both established strengths and persistent weaknesses.

Blood DKs maintain their trademark advantages:

• Unmatched self-sustainability through exceptional self-healing capabilities
• Reliable sustained damage with excellent potential via Anti-Magic Shell and Icebound Fortitude
• Anti-Magic Zone delivers incredible value this season for party survival against massive area damage
• Death Grip continues providing exceptional utility for managing stationary casters, which feature prominently in Season 2 dungeons

Longstanding deficiencies persist:

• Continuing struggles against high burst damage scenarios
• Difficulties managing large pulls in higher-level keys, particularly during high-pressure situations like Motherlode’s initial engagements
• These limitations present less concern for most pickup groups, where Blood DK remains a strong and viable tank option for weekly Mythic+ completion.

  While Blood DKs offer excellent survivability, they lack the high-end meta viability demonstrated by top-tier tanks—barring unexpected buffs.

  A Tier: Protection Paladin

  Protection Paladins claim second position as a powerful A-tier tank specialization. While they dominated Season 1 as undisputed leaders, their supremacy has diminished following multiple nerfs:

  • Reduced passive durability through Strength in Adversity adjustments
  • Extended cooldowns on critical defensive abilities including Divine Shield and Lay on Hands
  • Significant area-of-effect damage reductions

  These modifications result in Protection Paladins feeling less self-reliant compared to Season 1 with an overall diminished damage profile.

  Despite these adjustments, Protection Paladin remains an exceptionally strong tank with:

  • The most comprehensive utility toolkit among tank specializations for party support
  • Excellent synergy potential with Season 2’s probable meta healer—Discipline Priest
  • Essential support capabilities including Avenger’s Shield for interrupts, Lay on Hands, Blessing of Sacrifice, and Spellwarding (magic damage equivalent of Blessing of Protection)

  Though no longer dominant, Protection Paladins represent a top-tier selection, particularly within coordinated group environments.

  S Tier: Vengeance Demon Hunter

  Vengeance Demon Hunters occupy the top position with S-tier status. Substantial changes have resulted in:

  • Improved Soul Fragment economy enabling stronger self-sustain
  • Feed the Demon now requiring only one talent point, liberating additional talent selections
  • This modification facilitates powerful new build configurations, allowing Last Resort (cheat death mechanic) acquisition without compromising essential toolkit components

  Primary Advantages:

  • Metamorphosis represents the premier defensive cooldown across all tank specializations, making their tier set bonus exceptionally potent
  • Chaos Brand maintains S-tier buff status, amplifying your party’s magical damage output
  • Darkness now functions as a game-changing ability—with group-wide area damage presenting major concerns, this spell achieves MVP-level status for team preservation
  • Outstanding area control and interrupt capabilities that create crucial recovery windows for healers

  While Vengeance DH doesn’t dramatically outpace Protection Paladin, it distinguishes itself as the most comprehensively balanced tank for high-level Mythic+ progression during Season 2.

  Season 2’s Mythic+ environment fundamentally redefines tanking success metrics—survival now depends more on group capabilities than individual tank durability. This represents a fundamental role transformation requiring adjusted approaches and mindset shifts.

  The tanking paradigm has evolved significantly:

  • Reduced emphasis on personal cooldown management
  • Increased focus on shot-calling for interrupts, defensive cooldown coordination, and group synchronization.

    Primary threats now consist primarily of bleed damage, damage-over-time effects, and debilitating debuffs rather than blockable tankbuster abilities.

    Tank specialization balance has improved substantially compared to Season 1. This redistribution of responsibilities creates opportunities for enhanced teamwork and coordinated play, presenting positive challenges for groups willing to adapt their strategies accordingly.

    Season 2 delivers a markedly improved tanking experience that promises greater enjoyment and satisfaction.

    Pull Size Management Strategies

    Successful tanking in Season 2 requires careful assessment of your group’s collective capabilities rather than simply pushing personal survival limits. Consider implementing progressive pull testing during initial dungeon runs to establish comfortable parameters for your specific composition.

    Cooldown Optimization Techniques

    Mastering defensive cooldown sequencing becomes crucial—learn to layer minor cooldowns between major defensive activations for continuous damage mitigation.

    Group Coordination Essentials

    Develop clear communication protocols for critical moments. Establish interrupt rotations for dangerous spellcasters and coordinate personal defensive usage among DPS players during high-damage phases.

    Action Checklist

    • Test new talent builds on PTR focusing on bleed and magic damage mitigation
    • Practice pull size management with your regular healer to establish comfort zones
    • Master cooldown layering techniques for continuous damage reduction
    • Coordinate with your group to establish interrupt rotations and defensive cooldown usage protocols
    • Optimize racial selections if possible—Dwarf remains exceptionally strong for bleed removal

No reproduction without permission：OnLineGames Guides » WoW TWW 11.1 Undermine(d) Mythic+ Tank Tier List Comprehensive TWW Season 2 tanking guide with tier rankings, strategy insights, and optimization tips